TX SBOE not interested in hearing from experts, teachers

Click here for 40+ minute audioMeeting as the Committee of the Full Board Thursday night, November 19, the Texas State Board of Education made it clear that they are not interested in hearing any further from their “experts” or the writing teams of social studies specialists in their revision of social studies standards for the state of Texas. (Click here — or on the chimp — for the 40+ minute audio, or right-click to download and save — it’s a 5 Megabyte file, so it might take a while to load or download.)

Members Hardy, Craig, and Knight wanted to invite input from these specialists, but McLeroy, Leo, Cargill, Dunbar, and Mercer did not. One other member joined the vote to invite input (I’m guessing Berlanga or Nunez, but they were silent). The opposition comments are reported on the TFN Blog.

Mavis Knight pointed out that there would be a public comment period and a hearing in January-February, and that it would be helpful for the experts to be able to help the Board make proper use of that. It was clear, though, that Dunbar, McLeroy, et al. have already made up their minds what they will do, and have no intention of taking other input into consideration.

It seems that there is a majority that’s open to reconsidering particular names of historical persons for inclusion (or not) on the list of people who will be mentioned, or the list who could be mentioned in the history books, but otherwise they will make further changes on their own, listening only to favored sources that they’re already listening to, and they’re not interested in or open to anything else.


4 Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. […] honest, to the final Standards? It’s not too late … although their already-announced lack of interest in getting input from historians and educators cannot be a hopeful sign. This entry was written by Tony Whitson and posted on November 24, 2009 […]

  2. […] standards, textbooks An earlier post here on Curricublog reported (with audio, & link to video feed) on the Texas SBOE’s decision not to invite […]

  3. […] their good work is being threatened with rewriting by the Board members themselves, who are explicitly not interested in any further input or review by experts in the subject matter. What if every committee had to take time dealing with such issues, and […]

  4. […] Regrettably, the Board has previously made it clear that they’re not interested in input from the experts. […]

Post a Comment

Required fields are marked *

%d bloggers like this: